If you were seeking the Broadway musical least likely to achieve widespread theatrical success among the general public, it would probably be “Cats.” However, the second least-likely contender for success would be “Dear Evan Hansen.” Further down the list, you would encounter “Merrily We Roll Along,” a once-criticized but now celebrated Tony-winning production that has been recorded and released as a professionally shot stage performance.
Debuting in theaters this week, the Stephen Sondheim musical, “Merrily We Roll Along,” offers a unique experience in musical theater, diverging from the soothing narratives of productions like “Wicked” or Cynthia Erivo’s rendition of “Defying Gravity.” With its jazzy musical compositions and sharp tones, the show embraces a distinct style, even incorporating ironic mockery of its own tracks within the storyline.
The storyline of “Merrily We Roll Along” is complex and somber, leading to mass walkouts and a premature closure just two weeks after its original 1981 premiere. Based on the play by George S. Kaufman and Moss Hart, the musical narrates a tale of a three-way friendship in reverse chronological order, infused with elevated language and profound musings on life.
Despite its scattered nature and lack of commercial appeal, the production critiques accessible art and reveals its ending at the beginning, challenging the audience to grasp the significance of the characters’ journey. The show’s themes caution against the consequences of ambition, highlighting the sacrifices made in pursuit of success.
Over the years, “Merrily We Roll Along” underwent revisions and revivals, with substantial changes made to enhance its impact. Although initially a failure, the musical found redemption through the dedication of a superfan, Maria Friedman, and the performances of stars like Jonathan Groff and Daniel Radcliffe, leading to critical acclaim and multiple Tony awards.
The availability of a professionally recorded version of the stage play, known as a “pro-shot,” has provided broader access to the musical, a rarity in the theater world. This format allows audiences to experience the emotional intensity of the performances, capturing the nuances of the characters and their evolving relationships with precision.
While “Merrily We Roll Along” may not cater to showtune skeptics, its poignant exploration of friendship and ambition resonates with those willing to delve into its intricate narrative. The pro-shot version of the production offers a captivating blend of stage and film elements, delivering a compelling viewing experience that mirrors the intimacy of live theater.
In essence, “Merrily We Roll Along” may not replicate the traditional Broadway outing, but its immersive storytelling and powerful performances bring audiences remarkably close to the raw emotions and timeless themes portrayed on stage.